Disc 1. Act 1. Prologue/Overture (orchestra)
Beautiful girls (Roscoe, company)
Don't look at me (Sally, Ben)
Waiting for the girls upstairs (Buddy, Ben, Phyllis, Sally, Young Buddy, Young Ben, Young Phyllis, Young Sally)
Rain on the roof (Emily, Theodore)
The road you didn't take (Ben)
Bolero d'amore (orchestra)
Who's that woman? (Stella, Weismann girls)
I'm still here (Carlotta)
Too many mornings (Ben, Sally).
Disc 2. Act 2. The right girl (Buddy)
One more kiss (Heidi, Young Heidi)
Could I leave you? (Phyllis)
The folly of love: Loveland (company)
The folly of youth: You're gonna love tomorrow/Love will see us through (Young Ben, Young Phyllis, Young Buddy, Young Sally)
Buddy's folly: The God-why-don't-you-love-me blues (Mr. Buddy Plummer, Margie, Sally)
Sally's folly: Losing my mind (Mrs. Sally Durant Plummer)
Phyllis's folly: Ah, but underneath (Mrs. Phyllis Rogers Stone, male ensemble members)
Ben's folly: Live, laugh, love (Mr. Benjamin Stone, company)
Finale (Young Buddy, Young Ben, Young Phyllis, Young Sally, company)
The appendix. Bring on the girls (Roscoe, Young Roscoe) ; Can that boy fox-trot! (Carlotta) ; Pleasant little kingdom (Ben, Sally) ; All things bright and beautiful (Ben, Sally) ; That old piano roll (Buddy) ; Who could be blue?/Little white house (Mr. Benjamin Stone, Miss Phyllis Rogers) ; Uptown/Downtown (Mrs. Phyllis Rogers Stone, ensemble) ; The story of Lucy and Jessie (Mrs. Phyllis Rogers Stone, ensemble).
